[PS4] Uncharted 4 - A Thief's End

[LouBarlow]

Originally Posted by eye__writ

The best Uncharted game came out last year and was multi-platform, so they've got a lot to prove with this new one.

Ok I'll bite - huh?

[nsb]

Tomb Raider I imagine

[Fever Dawg]

Originally Posted by LouBarlow

I liked 1, but found it a bit finicky and unforgiving, controls wise. 2 was stunning.

I guess that narrows down the time you switched fanboyism.

[dunkle]

I loved all 3 of them, only games, other than last of us, I played to completion on ps3, actually probably only games I really played on it at all, and I still felt I had value for money

[eye__writ]

Originally Posted by nsb

Tomb Raider I imagine

[Mr Majestik]

Playing Tomb Raider now thanks to PSN+. It's good but it's no where near Uncharted quality. Far too many instant death qte's and poor level design sections.

[Fever Dawg]

Tomb Raider didn't have the humour and gameplay variation the Uncharted games have.

[LouBarlow]

Claiming that Tomb Raider is the best Uncharted game is a statement that could only come from a devout MS fanboy who has never even played an Uncharted game.

[eye__writ]

Originally Posted by LouBarlow

Claiming that Tomb Raider is the best Uncharted game is a statement that could only come from a devout MS fanboy who has never even played an Uncharted game.

I owned a PS3 and played all the Uncharted games to completion. They were fine.

Last of Us was magnificent, so no fanboism here.

[eye__writ]

Originally Posted by Fever Dawg

Tomb Raider didn't have the humour and gameplay variation the Uncharted games have.

The humour in Uncharted was very one-note. Enjoyable and endearing in parts, but nothing like witty enough to be a massive swing in its favour.

Gameplay wise, variation doesn't make up for the clunky controls in my opinion.

[PlexShaw]

Uncharted 2 and Tomb Raider 2013 are on the same level as far as I'm concerned. I absolutely adored both of them.

The Uncharted series are good games ruined by crappy combat, the same reason why I couldn't get on with The Last of Us. Overall I much prefered the Tomb Raider reboot.

[LordoftheDance]

There's an equation called Drake's formula which is quite easy to understand.

Uncharted 2 > Uncharted 3 > Tomb Raider

Simple.

[Fever Dawg]

Where does Uncharted 1 sit?

[ourmatetone]

I dismissed Uncharted originally, as I figured it for a Tomb Raider knock off. But, ironically enough, last year's TR reboot (which was my second favourite game of 2013) took quite a few cues from the Uncharted series. The tone is drastically different though, and the equipment Lara uses is more like something lifted from the Arkham games.

[LouBarlow]

Tomb Raider is a great game. I don't want to come across as dissing it, but it's not in the same league as Uncharted 2 or TLOU for me. I can't understand anyone having problems with the combat in TLOU.

Originally Posted by LouBarlow

I can't understand anyone having problems with the combat in TLOU.

I'm prepared to give it a second chance when it's available to play on a controller designed for human hands.

[LouBarlow]

Sausage fingers?

[barrynorton]

Originally Posted by ShakeyJake

I'm prepared to give it a second chance when it's available to play on a controller designed for human hands.

as opposed to a controller thats designed with the thumb in a different position on each hand?

Originally Posted by barrynorton

as opposed to a controller thats designed with the thumb in a different position on each hand?

However they get it to work is good by me. DS4 and Xbox 360/One pads are excellent and both put the analogues in different places.